La Russophobe has moved!

You should be automatically redirected in 6 seconds. If not, visit
and update your bookmarks.

Wednesday, January 17, 2007

Guilty Until Proven Innocent in Russia . . . and in Fact, maybe you're still guilty even then

The picture at the left adorned the front page of the Moscow Times website on Tuesday. It's a picture of VIP Bank Chief Alexei Frenkel (well, a picture of his suit jacket, anyway, he's the one behind bars), who according to the MT had just been arrested "on suspicion of organizing the murder of Andrei Kozlov, formerly the Central Bank's second-highest ranking official. Frenkel's arrest comes three days after that of Liana Askerova,who was charged Friday with involvement in the Sept. 13 killing."

Now don't be confused: The picture was not taken in a Moscow jail, but in a Moscow courtroom. You see, when you are accused of a crime in Russia you stand before the court behind bars, guilty until proven innocent . . . and maybe not even then.

One can't help but remark upon the wonderful convenience of it all. Let's say, just for the sake of argument, that the Kremlin didn't care for Andrei Kozlov. Let's say, for instance, that he was a crusading politico trying to clean corruption out of Russia's banking sector, and the oligarchs close to "President" Vladmir Putin didn't care for that much. So they kill him. But the fun doesn't stop there.

After they've killed him, you see, then they've got a perfect excuse to arrest other people they don't like and charge them with the crime. Of course, if they can't find anybody they don't like because they've already killed most of them, then they can simply pick somebody at random. In the worst case scenario, they can use the court system to cover their tracks; in the best case, they kill two jailbirds with one stone.

Isn't it romantic?


james24 said...

The incompetance of the Russian procuracy is being proven yet again. They can't even prosecute their legitimate cases correctly!

Apparently lawyers for this Alexei Frenkel guy aren't even allowed to meet with him. According to the lawyer Igor Trutnov, this constitutes a "violation of provisions of both the Russian Constitution, and the criminal code of procedure." (

Now I really hope that the murderers of the brave and incorruptible Andrei Kozlov are captured, investigated, and tried for their horrendous crime - but when the procuracy can't even fake a REAL trial, we're in big trouble.

La Russophobe said...

Hi James. Thanks for the comment and the link. I think we're getting to the point now where the Kremlin sees it as a basis for promotion if prosecutors violate the constitution. It's all quite depressing, not least for the deja vu.